Login / Register
When prices crash, economists blame it on supply-demand disequilibrium but fail to see the human suffering it unleashes. Not only in India but globally too, the volatility of the markets has destroyed livelihoods and increasingly forced farmers to abandon farming, sell off their lands and migrate to the cities looking for menial jobs. This is no less than mayhem. Take the case of America, where farm gate prices have been on a steady decline, gradually pushing farmers out of agriculture.
Updated At: Dec 23, 2021 05:19 AM (IST)
WHAT A WASTE: Destroying of crops by farmers is a sign of the distress afflicting the agricultural community. PTI
AT a time when wholesale price inflation has been the highest in three decades, there is distressing news on the farm front. Within a span of a week, three farmers have burnt their standing crops or the harvested produce at three different locations across the country. The crops are different, but the reason for putting it on fire is the same — failure to get a fair price that covers the actual cost farmers had incurred on its cultivation.
On December 11, an angry Chakalu Venkateswarlu, hailing from Kurnool district in Andhra Pradesh, put on fire the 25 bags of onions (each weighing 50 kg) that he had brought to the Kurnool Agricultural Market Yard, when he found the best price being offered to him was Rs 500 per quintal (Rs 5 per kg). Realising that such a low price did not even cover his cost of production, transportation and the mandi fee, the frustrated farmer preferred to sprinkle petrol on his produce and set it on fire.
Four days later, another farmer from Dhone mandal in Andhra Pradesh, put his 3 acres under banana plantation to fire when the prices in the wholesale market effectively crashed to Rs 2 to Rs 3 per kg. Mallikarjuna claims that he had spent about Rs 5 lakh in cultivating bananas, but when the prices fell so low at the time of the third harvest, he felt defeated. All that he had earned from marketing his crop was not more than Rs 1.5 lakh. Out of exasperation, therefore, he was left with little choice but to burn the plantation.
In Madhya Pradesh, a couple of days later, an irate Shankar Sirfira, a farmer from Deoli, burnt 160 kg of garlic that he had brought to the Mandsaur market yard. In the video clip that went viral on the social media, he was heard saying that he had spent Rs 2.5 lakh on cultivating garlic, but all he got in the market was Rs 1 lakh. This did not even cover the cost of cultivation. He said all he wanted from the government was to ensure a fair price to the farmers.
The three painful incidents that I have highlighted above may appear to be isolated but are a reflection of the deeper agrarian distress that prevails. There are tens of thousands of farmers cultivating the same crops who are lashed with the same ferocious blow from the markets but whose despair, dismay and hopelessness go unrecorded. When prices crash, economists blame it on supply-demand disequilibrium but fail to see the human suffering it unleashes. Not only in India but globally too, the volatility of the markets has destroyed livelihoods, and increasingly forced farmers to abandon farming, sell off their lands and migrate to the cities looking for menial jobs.
This is no less than mayhem. Take the case of America, where the farm gate prices have been on a steady decline since 150 years, thereby gradually pushing farmers out of agriculture. With a hollow disquiet prevailing in the countryside, not only have farm suicides increased but so has mental distress. In the US alone, from where we borrowed the failed market reforms in agriculture, as many as 915,725 farm workers and their families are being treated for depression at the Migrant Health Centres that have been set up nationwide. This is happening at a time when hardly 1.5 per cent of the US population now remains in farming. While there may be complex reasons behind the mental health challenges that farmers and farm workers are faced with, fluctuating commodity prices remain on the top.
But for policy planners and the media, especially business journalists, mayhem occurs only when equity indices plunge, when stock markets end at a lower level. This is how the economic design is cast. While a dominant section of the mainline economists rue the slide in stock markets, they spare no effort in welcoming the low farm prices that eventually leads to increased farm indebtedness, pushing more and more farmers to migrate to the urban centres.
No wonder, the daggers are already out against any possible move to provide farmers with a guaranteed income by way of a legal sanctity for Minimum Support Price (MSP) for 23 crops for which the prices are announced every year. Some senior economists, who themselves get a guaranteed salary packet linked to inflation every month, are the ones to talk about the virtues of free markets for farmers, which they believe would lead to price discovery. Although I have earlier talked in these columns of how the markets in case of highly commercial products like chocolate and coffee have left millions of primary growers of cocoa beans and coffee bean in Africa and Latin America to live in misery, the case of banana value chains squeezing farmers’ income is no less of an eye-opener. A study shows for every euro worth of purchase by the European consumers, banana producers in Latin America, from where the fruit is imported, receive only 5 to 9 per cent of the end price.
It is the primary producers who play a strenuous role, working the hardest, and yet their share of income in the agricultural value chains is the lowest, not even covering the cost of production. And let’s not forget. For the three commercially important crops — coffee beans, banana and cocoa beans — there is no MSP, nor is there any APMC mandis that we can point our fingers to. It is the big multinationals operating in a competitive environment that actually thrive on sucking farmers’ wealth. Imagine, if the global agricultural chains had set an example by guaranteeing a minimum economic price covering the cost of production plus a reasonable share of profits, farming too would have been a profitable enterprise.
Instead of leaving it to exploitative market forces, as the international evidence has conclusively shown, the time is ripe for India to usher in a new set of ingenious farm reforms that begins by first ensuring a living income for farmers. Guaranteeing an economically viable livelihood to 50 per cent of the country’s population is the way to bridge the great economic divide.
What do you think? (Share your feedback)
Lookout notice against Bikram Singh Majithia; FIR points to sand, drug trade link
11 Bills passed; session ends one day ahead of schedule
Government, opposition spar over House disruptions
Winter session goes down as third most unproductive
MPs should debate, discuss, not disrupt, says LS Speaker Om Birla
New Parliament building by next year
PM Modi to hold review meet today amid Omicron concerns
Delhi bans Xmas, New Year parties to check Covid surge
ASHA workers protest outside Punjab Deputy CM's house in Amritsar for hike in wages
Amritsar MC fails to achieve recovery targets, says AAP
People can't be divided along communal lines, says Navjot Singh Sidhu
Philanthropy: Two Amritsar teachers nominated for Erasmus Causa
Vendors at Amritsar railway station count losses
Chandigarh MC Elections: Candidates go online in a big way, meet voters one-on-one
3,700 police personnel to ensure peaceful poll in Chandigarh
Despite high fuel prices, Chandigarh has only 1,791 e-vehicles
Omicron threat: Chandigarh to activate 'war room' soon
In death, little Anaika gives a new lease of life to 5 patients
Only AC-3 tier earned Railways profit: CAG report
Some relief, minimum temperature to rise: IMD
DDMA bans Christmas, New Year gatherings in Delhi; asks district magistrates to identify superspreader areas
Delhi Police file chargesheet in Rohini court shootout case
Omicron: Genome sequencing of samples of all Covid cases starts in Delhi
Guru Nanak Dev University semester exams likely in first week of January
Two gangsters nabbed, weapons seized in Kapurthala
‘Suicide bid’ by teachers protesting outside education minister Pargat Singh’s residence
Jalandhar: Sculptures, tapestries attract visitors at Virsa Vihar
Theatrics won't help Cong, Akalis: Bhagwant Mann
Woman among 3 nabbed with 4.19-quintal 'beef' in Ludhiana
Garment shop gutted in fire at Gandhi Nagar market in Ludhiana
Dispose of senior citizen's case expeditiously: Punjab and Haryana High Court to rent controller
Hindu holy books found 'dumped' under tree outside Ludhiana Mini Secretariat
25-year-old youth dies in accident in Ludhiana
2 UK returnees test positive in Patiala, health department begins contact tracing
Rs 8.25L robbery case solved, 3 held in Patiala
Punjabi University starts digitisation of rare manuscripts at Dehradun centre
Punjabi University, Patiala, allows online classes for Afghan students
The Tribune, now published from Chandigarh, started publication on February 2, 1881, in Lahore (now in Pakistan). It was started by Sardar Dyal Singh Majithia, a public-spirited philanthropist, and is run by a trust comprising four eminent persons as trustees.
The Tribune, the largest selling English daily in North India, publishes news and views without any bias or prejudice of any kind. Restraint and moderation, rather than agitational language and partisanship, are the hallmarks of the paper. It is an independent newspaper in the real sense of the term.
The Tribune has two sister publications, Punjabi Tribune (in Punjabi) and Dainik Tribune (in Hindi).
Remembering Sardar Dyal Singh Majithia
Designed and Developed by: Grazitti Interactive